Parliaments in Security Policy: Involvement, Politicisation, and Influence

Special Issue, British Journal of Politics and International Relations

The British Journal of Politics and International Relations (BJPIR) has published a Special Issue, guest edited by Patrick A. Mello and Dirk Peters: “Parliaments in Security Policy: Involvement, Politicisation, and Influence”.

The special issue focuses on the pivotal democratic institution – parliament – to study legislative involvement in security matters and its effects on policy outcomes. The contributing articles employ a diverse set of theoretical perspectives and methods to explore the role of 11 different parliamentary bodies from a broad range of contemporary Western democracies.

While parliaments have long been neglected actors in the analysis of security policy, a research literature on the subject is growing. Current research is focused primarily on how parliaments, relying on formal legal competences, can constrain governmental policies. However, this research needs expansion in three areas. First, informal sources of parliamentary influence on security policy deserve more systematic attention as the significance of parliaments often hinges on contextual factors and individual decision-makers. Second, we still lack a systematic understanding of the effects of parliamentary involvement on security policy. Finally, the role of parliaments for the politics of security is almost completely uncharted territory. When parliaments become involved in security policy, does it foster transparency and contribute to the politicisation of security policy so that security policy becomes a ‘normal’ political issue? The article reviews current research, derives findings from the contributions to this Special Issue, and spells out their wider implications.

Introduction to the Special Issue:

Parliaments in Security Policy: Involvement, Politicisation, and Influence

Mello, Patrick A., and Dirk Peters, eds. 2018. Parliaments in Security Policy: Involvement, Politicisation, and Influence. British Journal of Politics and International Relations 20 (1), 3-190.

DOI PDFCitationDemocratic peaceLegislative studiesParliamentsSecurity policyWar powers

Contributing Articles (in alphabetical order):

Towards ‘Normal’ Politics? Security, Parliaments and the Politicisation of Intelligence Oversight in the German Bundestag

Hegemann, Hendrik (2018) ‘Towards ‘Normal’ Politics? Security, Parliaments and the Politicisation of Intelligence Oversight in the German Bundestag‘, British Journal of Politics and International Relations 20 (1), 175-190.

DOICitation Intelligence Normal politics Parliamentary debates Politicisation Securitisation
Prime Minister Leadership Style and the Role of Parliament in Security Policy

Kaarbo, Juliet (2018) ‘Prime Minister Leadership Style and the Role of Parliament in Security Policy‘, British Journal of Politics and International Relations 20 (1), 35-51.

DOICitation Leadership style Parliamentary debates Personality Prime ministers International security
Congress, Public Opinion, and an Informal Constraint on the Commander-in-Chief

Kriner, Douglas L. (2018) ‘Congress, Public Opinion, and an Informal Constraint on the Commander-in-Chief‘, British Journal of Politics and International Relations 20 (1), 52-68.

DOICitation Congress President Public opinion Survey experiment Parliamentary war powers
The Unintended Consequences of Parliamentary Involvement: Elite Collusion and Afghanistan Deployments in Canada and Germany

Lagassé, Philippe, and Patrick A. Mello. 2018. The Unintended Consequences of Parliamentary Involvement: Elite Collusion and Afghanistan Deployments in Canada and GermanyBritish Journal of Politics and International Relations 20 (1), 135-157.

DOI Preprint PDFDataCitationElite collusionDeployment votesParliamentUnintended consequencesWar powers
Chamber of Opportunities: Legislative Politics and Coalition Security Policy

Oktay, Sibel (2018) ‘Chamber of Opportunities: Legislative Politics and Coalition Security Policy‘, British Journal of Politics and International Relations 20 (1), 104-120.

DOICitation Military coalitions Gaza Iraq War Logrolling Party politics
Parliament as an Arena for Politicization: The Finnish Eduskunta and Crisis Management Operations

Raunio, Tapio (2018) ‘Parliament as an Arena for Politicization: The Finnish Eduskunta and Crisis Management Operations‘, British Journal of Politics and International Relations 20 (1), 158-174.

DOICitation Crisis management Finland Parliamentary debates Party politics Politicisation International security
Influence Beyond Formal Powers: The Parliamentarisation of European Union Security Policy

Rosén, Guri, and Kolja Raube (2018) ‘Influence Beyond Formal Powers: The Parliamentarisation of European Union Security Policy‘, British Journal of Politics and International Relations 20 (1), 69-83.

DOICitation Common Foreign and Security Policy European Parliament European Union Informal influence Parliamentarisation International security
Limiting or Liberating? The Influence of Parliaments on Military Deployments in Multinational Settings

Schade, Daniel (2018) ‘Limiting or Liberating? The Influence of Parliaments on Military Deployments in Multinational Settings‘, British Journal of Politics and International Relations 20 (1), 84-103.

DOICitation Common Security and Defence Policy (CSDP) Parliamentary war powers Parliamentary debates Peacekeeping International security
The War Powers of the British Parliament: What Has Been Established and What Remains Unclear?

Strong, James (2018) ‘The War Powers of the British Parliament: What Has Been Established and What Remains Unclear?‘, British Journal of Politics and International Relations 20 (1), 19-34.

DOICitation Convention Use of force Parliamentary debates United Kingdom Parliamentary war powers
Is There a Parliamentary Peace? Parliamentary Veto Power and Military Interventions from Kosovo to Daesh

Wagner, Wolfgang (2018) ‘Is There a Parliamentary Peace? Parliamentary Veto Power and Military Interventions from Kosovo to Daesh‘, British Journal of Politics and International Relations 20 (1), 121-134.

DOICitation Democratic peace Iraq War Kosovo Military intervention Parliamentary peace Veto power